Carotid body tumors and the outcomes

A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Presentation and Surgical Management of Patients With Carotid Body Tumours.

Vaux Robertson

, 

Federica Poli

, 

Ben Hobson

, 

Athanasios Saratzis

, 

A. Ross Naylor∗,Correspondence information about the author A. Ross NaylorEmail the author A. Ross Naylor

The Leicester Vascular Institute, Glenfield Hospital, Leicester UK

Objectives

The aim was to determine the mode of presentation and 30 day procedural risks in 4418 patients with 4743 carotid body tumours (CBTs) undergoing surgical excision.

Methods

This is a systematic review and meta-analysis of 104 observational studies.

Results

Overall, 4418 patients with 4743 CBTs were identified. The mean age was 47 years, with the majority being female (65%). The commonest presentation was a neck mass (75%), of which 85% were painless. Dysphagia, cranial nerve injury (CNI), and headache were present in 3%, while virtually no one presented with a transient ischaemic attack (0.26%) or stroke (0.09%). The majority (97%) underwent excision, but only 21% underwent pre-operative embolisation. Overall, 27% were Shamblin I CBTs; 44% were Shamblin II; and 29% were Shamblin III. The mean 30 day mortality was 2.29% (95% CI 1.79–2.93). The mean 30 day stroke rate was 3.53% (95% CI 2.91–4.29), while the mean 30 day CNI rate was 25.4% (95% CI 24.5–31.22). The prevalence of persisting CNI at 30 days was 11.15% (95% CI 8.42–14.64). Twelve series (544 patients) correlated 30 day stroke with Shamblin status. Shamblin I CBTs were associated with a 1.89% stroke rate (95% CI 0.92–3.82), increasing to 2.71% (95% CI 1.43–5.07) for Shamblin II CBTs and 3.99% (95% CI 2.34–6.74) for Shamblin III tumours. Twenty-six series (1075 patients) correlated CNI rates with Shamblin status: 3.76% (95% CI 2.62–5.35) for Shamblin I CBTs, 14.14% (95% CI 11.94–16.68) for Shamblin II, and 17.10% (95% CI 14.82–19.65) for Shamblin III tumours. The prevalence of neck haematoma requiring re-exploration was 5.24% (95% CI 3.45–7.91). The proportion of patients with a neck haematoma requiring re-exploration was not reduced by pre-operative embolisation (5.92%; 95% CI 2.56–13.08) vs. no embolisation (5.82%; 95% CI 2.76–11.88). Pre-operative embolisation did not reduce drainage losses (639 mL vs. 653 mL).

Conclusions

This is the largest meta-analysis of outcomes after CBT excision. Procedural risks associated with tumour excision were considerable, especially with Shamblin III tumours where 4% suffered a peri-operative stroke and 17% suffered a CNI.